The Eyewitness in the Empty Room
From Swami Rama Tirtha’s lecture “The Sun of Self on the Wall of Mind” · Timestamp 20:50–22:28
When you get up, you say, "I slept so profoundly that I saw nothing in the dreams." There we say, please write this statement on paper. Then Vedanta comes up and says that this statement is just like a statement made by a man who said that at the dead of night, at such and such a place, there was not a single being present. The judge told him to put that statement on paper, and he did that. The judge asked him if this statement was true. He said, 'yes'. 'Is this statement made on hearsay, or is it founded on your own evidence? Are you an eyewitness?' He said, 'yes, I am'. 'All right. Then, if you were an eyewitness and if you wish us to understand that your statement is correct, that there was nobody present, then in order that your statement may be right, you at least must have been present on the scene. But if you were present on the scene, this statement is not literally true. Literally, the statement is not true, because you being a human being you were present; at least one human being was present on the scene. Thus the statement that nobody was present, that there was not a single human being present on the scene, is false, that is a contradictory statement. In order that it may be true as you wish us to understand it to be true, it must be wrong. It must be wrong because at least one human being must have been present on the scene.'